Showing posts with label Jean Nicolas Corvisart. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Jean Nicolas Corvisart. Show all posts

Friday, October 7, 2016

1854: M. Priory fine tunes stethoscope and percussion

Pierre Adolph Priory (1794-1879)
Joseph Auenbrugger, Jean Corvisart, and Rene Laennec introduced the medical community to chest percussion and auscultation.  Both techniques became valuable for helping physicians diagnose diseases of the chest, although both needed to be perfected.  

By the time of his death in 1826, Rene Laennec saw his invention of the stethoscope become accepted by his peers.  However, he would readily admit that his new tool was not yet perfected. He would spend many hours himself improving upon it, and when he died this task was left to his peers.

Pierre Adolph Piorry (often referred to as M. Priory due to his French origin) was born in 1794, served in the Napoleanic wars in Spain, and served at the Atarazanas Hospital in Spain where he was able to witness military surgery." (1, page 675)

In 1814 he returned to his medical practice in France, and, like Laennec, served as a student of Corvisart. He qualified as a physician in 1816, the same year Laennec invented his stethoscope.  (1, page 675)

This is a picture of the Priory binaural stethoscope complete with
the pleximeter(round, solid ivory disks on bottom second from left)
and fingerthimble ivory percussor (on botton right).  Picture from 1828.
Photo from http://www.antiquemed.com/binaural_stethoscope.htm
He had a gift as a teacher, and between 1817 and 1826 he delivered lectures on physiology and pathology.  In 1826 he was appointed physician to the Paris Hospital.  In 1837, after many years of attempting to do so, he became professor of medicine at Paris School of Medicine (l'Hospital de la Pitie, Paris).  He was 43.  (1, page 676)

He then took off where Laennec left off, working hard to fine tune the binaural stethoscope.  The product he ended up with would be the general design of most stethoscopes used for the rest of the 19th century.  He also worked to improve the technique of percussion.  His work in this area created excitement for the remainder of the century, although it would ultimately be for naught. (1, page 675)

A Classic Reprint Series of Priory's book
is proof his ideas are still sought after.
The first edition was published in 1826.
His stethoscope was trumpet shaped and made of wood, although it was shorter and thinner than Laennec's.  It came with a removable wood plug, ivory earpiece and chest piece, with the chest piece also serving as a pleximeter (described below).  This design was also much more pleasing to physicians, and was much easier to carry in their bags. (5)

In a 1979 Biography of Priory, Alex Sakula said of Priory:
Priory, enthused by Laennec's invention, developed an ambition to emulate the great master and to achieve fame in some similar fashion. Priory describes in his poem Dieu L'ame et Nature how he came to study percussion.  He prayed to God asking to be able to make some discovery like that of Laennec.  A few months later, he had slight pruritus and while scratching the skin over his chest he heard a sound.  He interposed a coin and scraped it and obtained a stronger sound, which varied according to the density and elasticity of the underlying organ." (1, page 577)
This is a picture of Priory's Pleximeter. (5, page 311)
Sakula said that the next day he began his work on percussion, and hoped that what Laennec had done for auscultation he could do for percussion.  On February 28, 1826, he "read a prize winning paper on his new method of percussion to the Academie Royale de Medecine.  Laennec (then very near his death) was one of those present." (1, page 577)

Scott Alison, in his 1861 book, "The physical examination of the
 chest," described the procedure of percussion as follows: 
 The pleximeter is to be placed in or over an intercostal space,
 or upon a flat surface, and fitted well with gentle pressure upon
 the body,and held by the thumb and forefinger of the left hand. 
It may be employed together with a hammer or with the fingers." 
A percussion hammer is sown here.  (5, page 311
In the paper, Sakula said, Priory described his new technique of doing percussion, which involved placing a small plate between the patient's skin and the percussing finger.  He called the plate a pleximeter from the Greek words to strike and to measure. (1, page 577)

This little gadget shows the extent that some physicians went to 
create the perfect pleximeter.  Scott Alison described it as:
"An instrument combining both a pleximeter and a hammer 
was contrived by Dr. Aldis some years ago. It consistsof a
 hammer moving on a fulcrum, and of a disc of cork which 
receives the blow of the hammer. The cork disc is placed 
upon the chest, and the hammer is raised by the finger to the
 required height. The higher the hammer is raised, the more force
 is obtained. The hammer falls by the operation of a spring.
 Great uniformity of blow is obtained by this instrument. 
This ingenious contrivance has obtained the name of 
echometer." (5, page 312)


As Laennec experimented with various materials while trying to perfect his stethoscope, Priory experimented with various materials while trying to perfect his pleximeter, said Priory, "but finally settled on a small ivory plate, 5 cm in diameter.  He also devised a combined stethoscope and pleximeter made of ivory and cedar wood." (1, page 577)

These are a few of the varieties of wooden binaural stethoscopes
in use by physicians as of 1861. (5, page 316)
After all the publicity that the stethoscope had garnished since Laennec introduced it in 1819, percussion had lost some of its luster.  Some probably believed the stethoscope would replace it completely.  (1, pages 576-577)

However, Sakula said:
"Piorry did not regard percussion as competing with auscultation, and taught that the two techniques were supplementary one to another." (1, page 577)
This is a flexible stethoscope.  In his 1861 book, Scott Alison said,
"In employing the flexible stethoscope, it is even more necessary
than in the case of the wooden instrument to observe that the object
end is well applied so as to close the tube.  If left partially open,
scarcely any sound is perceived. (5, page 321)
There were still many physicians who did not adapt his stethoscope and pleximeter.  Many who finally accepted his research on percussion came up with their own techniques for performing the procedure.  For instance, the preferred method became the use of the finger of one hand used as the pleximeter, and the finger of the other hand as the percussor.  Yet the principle is the same.  (1, page 577)

The Cyclopaedia of Practical medicine, edited in part by John Forbes, best concludes the accomplishments of Priory regarding percussion: (3, page 7)
M. Priory, a young Parisian physician, has the honor of having, if not invented, at least brought into a formal and matured shape, this new application of the discovery of Auenbrugger, and with practical results greater precision and importance than could have been anticipated. (3, page 7)
Dr. Sibson's pleximeter 
consists of a plate of 
ivory which receives
the blow, and of a brass
hammer or weight
working in a metal frame.
. The weight or hammer
is raised by the fingers;
these being removed, 
the weight or hammer 
falls upon the ivory plate
by the elasticity of an
indiarubber band connecting 
the weight or hammer 
with the ivory plate.
The hammer works
perpendicularly
to the plate. (5, page 313
Like many new tools invented or discovered to assist physicians do their jobs better, the Priory stethoscope and pleximeter were not accepted by all physicians.

Piorry remained a famous physician until his retirement at the age of 72 in 1866.  He died at age 85 in 1879.

Yet long before he passed from this world his hard work paid off.  By 1854 percussion had been fine tuned so that it was often performed not just over the chest, but over various organs of the body to help doctors diagnose any pathological disorders.

While there were various stethoscopes designed during the remainder of the 19th century after Priorry's death, most were adaptations of his design.  Examples include binaural stethoscopes made by Quain, Stokes, Arnold, Barclay, Elliotson, Dobell, Loomis, Burrow, Clark, Camman, and Furguson. (4, page 626)

These other stethoscopes were made of various materials, produced by various manufacturers, and were scattered through various publications.  Still, Priory's stethoscope remained the most popular design for the remainder of the century.

References:  
  1. Sakula, Alex., "Pierre Adolphe Piorry (1794-1879): pioneer of percussion and pleximetry," October, 1979, Thorax ( 34(5): 575–581).  
  2. "The Binaural Stethoscope," antiquemed.com, http://www.antiquemed.com/binaural_stethoscope.htm, information reviewed March 8, 2012
  3. Forbes, John, Alexander Weedie, Conolly, editors, "The cyclopaedia of practical medicine," volume 1, London, 1833
  4. Camman, Donald M, "Historical Sketch: Stethoscopes," A Reference Handbook for Medical Sciences, edited by Albert Henry Buck, by various writers, volume VI, 1888, New York, William Wood and Company, 626-628
  5. Alison, Somerville Scott, "The physical examination of the chest in pulmonary consumption and its intercurrent diseases," 1861, London, John Churchill
RT Cave Facebook Page
RT Cave on Twitter
Print Friendly and PDF

Monday, June 27, 2016

1816: Laennec invents the stethoscope

Figure 1 --Rene Laennec (1781-1826).  Along with
crediting an old kid's game with giving him the idea of
creating his first stethoscope, he was also skilled with
the flute.  His memory and his musical skill  helped him
come up with the ingenious plan of rolling up paper into
a hollow tube.  He then used this to listen to lung sounds.
He later modestly chimed that he was amazed the device
wasn't invented years ago.  Hippocrates was known for
performing auscultation by placing his ear upon his
patient's chest.  A simple stethoscope would have
greatly benefited the ancient physician. (4, page xxiii)
Before the 19th century the only way for a physician to auscultate (hear) heart and lung sounds was to place his ear upon his patent's chest.  This would change thanks to a brilliant invention by French Physician Rene Laennec.

A procedure called Immediate Auscultation was probably used by priest/physicians in ancient Egypt, although it was first described for the medical community around 400 B.C. by Hippocrates.

Laennec quotes Hippocrates from De Morbis:
auYou shall know by this that the chest contains water and not pus, if in applying the ear during a certain time on the side, you perceive a noise like that of boiling vinegar. (4, pages 28-29) 
Immediate auscultation, or placing an ear directly on the chest of the patient, was never further investigated by the successors of Hippocrates, and therefore never became standard practice.  (4, page 29)

Not helping matters was the fact that most people did not take regular baths, and sick people were sometimes hot and wet from sweat.  Laennec said that it was flat out disgusting. (4, pages 29)

Also not helping matters was the fact that it was not gentlemanly to do this to a lady, and that fat tissue muffles sound.

When he was 38-years-old on a hot and humid day in 1816, Rene Theophile Hyacinthe Laennec was posed with all of these problems, yet the need to auscultate his patient's heart and lung sounds was essential.

He came up with an ingenious plan that helped him assess his patient, yet which also helped him improve the assessment skills for all physicians.

Who was Rene Laenec? 

Laennec was born on February 17, 1781, to to an an "advocate of the provincial courts, and held some appointments under government, in his native country (France)... Fortunately his son was heir of the more solid parts of his genius; without his wit, but without his volatility.  (1, page xix)

At an early age he was put under the care of his uncle, a clergy man in charge of the parish of Eliam, in the vicinity of Quimper.  However, after the French Revolution broke out his care was transferred to another uncle, Dr. Laennec of Nanates. (1, page xix)
Dr. Laennec was a man of highest respectability both as to talent and conduct, and directed the studies of his nephew with the interest and affection of a parent. The young scholar did credit to his friends and teachers; having obtained considerable distinction from his fellows at the chief school of the department of the Lower Loire, wither he had been sent by his uncle. Having completed his preparatory studies at this seminary, his thoughts naturally turned towards physic as a profession. He willingly engaged himself as the pupil of his uncle, and entered upon the study of his future profession with the zeal inherent in his character, and with success indicative of his subsequent eminence. Besides the instructions derived from his uncle, who was at that time senior physician of the hospital, and afterwards Professor of Medicine and Materia Medica at Nantes, he attended the courses of anatomy given by the surgeons of the same establishment, and is said, even at this early age, to have shown a decided predilection for morbid anatomy and clinical observation.(1, page xix)
Figure 2 --
Shown here:  Matthew Baille (1761-1823)
While under the tutelage of Corvisant,
Laennec became good friends with
Matthew Baillie.  Ironically, both were
famous for their studies of diseases of
the lungs, and both were diagnosed with
consumption,and eventually died of this disease.  
In 1800 he attended the medical school of La Charite, which was where he came to tutelage of a well respected and well known physician by the name of Jean Nicolas Corvisant.  He also became good friends at this school with Matthew Baillie, who himself would go on to gain great fame as a physician.  (1, page x)

He had actually gained recognition earlier in his career, for while in school he wrote a history of medicine, and, in the year 1802 at the age of 21, published articles that were well received by his fellow physicians.  (1, page x)

He opened a clinic in and began seeing patients.  In 1816 he was appointed chief physician to the Necker Hospital.  It was here where he was presented with the opportunity whereby he came up with an ingenious plan that changed medical diagnosis forever.  (1, page xxiii)

What was Laennec's ingenious plan? 

So on a hot and humid day in 1816, a 36-year-old physician by the name of Rene Laennec came up with an ingenious plan.

According to Kendall F. Haven in his book "One hundred greatest inventions of all time," Laennec was a "well established doctor and diagnostician of chest and abdominal disorders when he was asked by a fellow physician to assess an obese young woman with breathing difficulties." (2, page 96)

Not that it matters, but, for the record, the patient's name was Marie-Melanie Basset, and she was only 40.

Haven said:
Laenec's normal technique was to have the woman partially disrobe so he could place his ear against a hanker chief over her chest.  He'd listen to lung sounds over five spots:  the underside of each arm, each side of upper back, and upper breast bone. 
Figure 3 --
Gabriel Andral (1797-1876)
He was a French pathologist at the
University of Paris.  He is best known
for his work on blood chemistry.
Andral wrote the comments in
the margins of the 1838 edition
of Laennec's book.
Yet when he did this on this Marie, he heard nothing.  So he tried percussion, a method of tapping on the chest to check for dull or resonant sounds that might indicate certain diseases. Yet this method proved useless as well.

Thinking off the cuff, Haven said, he "grabbed 24 sheets of paper, rolled them tightly into a bundle, and secured them in shape with paste glue. He applied one end of this paste roll against the young woman's chest, and the other to his ear." (2, page 97)

Leanecc was "delighted" to learn he could hear the woman's heart and lung sounds better this way than with the unaided ear against her chest.  He was so excited at how simple a device could make this job so much easier that he set out to do a series of experiments to find metals and tubes that would aid his ear in hearing heart and lung sounds.  (2, page 96)

He actually wanted to name the device le cylindre claiming it was frivolous to name such a device.  However, his colleagues thought it should have a name, and they came up with some of their own. Yet once he decided he didn't like any of these names, he decided to call it a stethoscope.  Stethe coming from the Greek term for chest, and scope coming from the Latin term for aim.  (2, page 97)

His stethoscope was actually a monaural stethoscope, meaning that it had only one ear piece.  You can see a picture of his monaural stethoscope in figure 4.

How did Laennec come up with his idea?

In his book "A treaties on the diseases of the chest, and on mediate auscultation," Laennec recollected a little kid's game, and it was this that gave him an idea.

He wrote:
In 1816, I was consulted by a young woman laboring under general symptoms of diseased heart, and in whose case percussion and the application of the hand were of little avail on account of the great degree of fatness. The other method just mentioned (auscultating with an ear to the chest) being rendered inadmissible by the age and sex of the patient, I happened to recollect a simple and well-known fact in acoustics, and fancied it might be turned to some use on the present occasion. The fact I allude to is the great distinctness with which we hear the scratch of a pin at one end of a piece of wood, on applying our ear to the other. Immediately, on this suggestion, I rolled a quire of paper into a kind of cylinder and applied one end of it to the region of the heart and the other to my ear, and was not a little surprised and pleased, to find that I could thereby perceive the action of the heart in a manner much more clear and distinct than I had ever been able to do by the immediate application of the ear. (4, page 6)
Figure 4 -- Laennec's Monaural Stethoscope (1820).  It was an inch
and a half in diameter and a foot long, perforated longitudinally
by a bore three lines wide, and hollowed out into a funnel shape
at one end to the depth of an inch and a half. A plug of wood
was fitted into this hollowed extremity with a perforation through
it of the same diameter as that of the rest of the tube. The plug
was used in auscultating heart sounds, and discarded in
 stethoscopes made at a later date. It was made in two sections
for convenience of carrying. (6, page 626)  Perhaps it
 provided some solace to Laennec that he was diagnosed with
consumption using a stethoscope similar to this. Photo Copyright
Science Museum/ Science and SocietyPicture Library
So he thereby discovered that his invention was better for hearing sounds inside the human body than the ear alone.

What was the first stethoscope like? 

Laennec described his first stethoscope in his book Mediate Auscultation:
The first instrument which I used was a cylinder of paper, formed of three quires, compactly rolled together, and kept in shape by paste. The longitudinal aperture which is always left in the centre of paper thus rolled, led accidentally in my hands to an important discovery. (4, page 7)
He  also set off on a quest to study and perform experiments using the device, and he fine tuned it until he came up with a better product.  He trialed a variety of materials, lengths, and sizes of aperture, until he came up with the product he thought was idea.

He said:
In consequence of these various experiments I now employ a cylinder of wood, an inch and a half in diameter, and a foot long, perforated longitudinally by a bore three lines wide, and hollowed out into a funnel-shape, to the depth of an inch and a half at one of its extremities. It is divided into two portions, partly for the convenience of carriage, and partly to permit its being used of half the usual length. The instrument in this form—that is, with the funnel-shaped extremity,—is used in exploring the respiration and rhonchus: when applied to the exploration of the heart and the voice, it is converted into a simple tube, with thick sides, by inserting into its excavated extremity a stopper or plug traversed by a small aperture, and accurately adjusted to. the excavation. (See figure 2)  (10, page 7)
What other experiments did Laennec perform with his stethoscope?

While his binaural stethoscope made it easy for him to hear the various sounds inside the chest, he soon realized that he had a rare opportunity to advance upon what was already known about diseases of the chest.

This in mind, he used his new tool to study diseases of the chest, matching what he observed what he observed while his patients were alive with what he found on autopsy after death.  He said:
From this moment I imagined that the circumstance might furnish means for enabling us to ascertain the character, not only of the action of the heart, but of every species of sound produced by the motion of all the thoracic viscera, and, consequently, for the exploration of the respiration, the voice, the rhonchus (the sound of air flowing through diseased air passages), and perhaps even the fluctuation of fluid extravasated (leaked) in the pleura (sack around the lungs) or the pericardium (sack around the heart). (4, page 6)
Figure 3 -- Laennec listens to man with tuberculosis*
He took upon this opportunity to study diseases of the chest at the Necker Hospital where he also received patients at his clinic.  He therefore bravely came into close contact with some of the sickest and contagious people in France at the time, which can be seen in figure 3.  It was this type of dedication to his work whereby he contacted the disease that ended up ending his life.

How was the stethoscope accepted by Laennec's peers? 

Despite how useful he found this new tool in diagnosing and researching diseases of the chest, it was initially rejected by his peers in the medical community.
"What a ridiculous idea," his colleagues would say.  "We doctors are called upon for our brilliant medical minds.  To say we should carry some frivolous tool around with us is absolutely ridiculous and below us." 
This is a plate of the parts of the Laennec's stethoscope
as it appeared in the first edition of his book in 1819.
(4, pages 783) 
Another doctor wrote, "He that hath ears to hear, let him use his ears and not a stethoscope."

This was yet another example of a dogmatic and proud medical profession refusing to accept anything new or different. For thousands of years physicians rejected any scientific idea that opposed Galen's superstitions, and now they flat out rejected a tool that would allow them to do their jobs better.

Perhaps under the encouragement of Corvisart, Laennec published a book reporting what both he and Corvisart had learned about the diseases of the chest by using their new discoveries: chest percussion, vocal fremitus, and the stethoscope.

The book was published in 1819 and titled "De Auscultation Mediate, ou Traitt du Diagnostic des Maladies despoumons ct du Cceur, fonde principalement sur ce nouveau moyen. (A treaties on the diseases of the chest, and on mediate auscultation)" 

The book was well received, and, in 1821, it was translated into English by John Forbes (whose book was referenced in writing this post).

Slowly over the next few years his hard work payed off.  So even though he only lived six years after his discovery, he was able to see its acceptance before he passed away in 1826.

Perhaps there was no better evidence as to his tool's usefulness than by his own perseverance in studying the various diseases of the chest, a quest which may have ultimately cost him his life.  


Figure 4 -- Painting of Laennec using his stethoscope on a boy.
This picture was taken from a painting by Robert Thom,
copyrighted in 1960.  
Conclusion:

Laennec married in 1824 and had two children. However, he was only able to enjoy his young family for a short time.

He continued to work arduously at his clinic, both seeing physicians and performing research.

He also worked hard in perfecting the book he became famous for, releasing the second edition in 1826.  Subsequent editions were then published by John Forbes.

In the process of accomplishing this, along with his other duties as a physician and researcher, he became so exhausted that he was forced to give up his work and return to the home he was born in. Although some say he was simply tired from being ridiculed by his colleagues.

Either way, he was ultimately diagnosed with phthsis pulmonalis, which is the Latin form of consumption, or tuberculosis.  Ironically, he was diagnosed with the very same tool he invented.  Perhaps this was consolation, proof that the passion of his life's work was finally accepted.

He passed away on August 13, 1826,

In the ensuing years his invention adjusted by others, and eventually a stethoscope with two ear pieces (binaural) was invented. In 1852 George Camman fine tuned the stethoscope so it was similar to the models we use today.

References:
  1. Forbes, John, The life of the author, translator of "A treaties on the diseases of the chest, and on mediate auscultation," a book written by Rene Theophile Hyacinthe Laennec, 1838, New York, Philadelphia, Samuel S., pages xix-xxiii
  2. Haven, Kendall F, "One hundred greatest inventions of all time," 2006, U.S., Greenwood Publishing Group, Inc., pages 96-98
  3. "Now I hear:  The history of the stethoscope,"  http://antiquemed.com/, 1998-2011, accessed 12/28/13
  4. Laennec, Rene Theophile Hyacinthe, "A treaties on the diseases of the chest, and on mediate auscultation," translated by John Forbes, notes by Dr. M. Andral, 4th edition, 1838, New York, Philadelphia, Samuel S. and William Wood, Thomas Cowperthwaite and Company
  5.  Barchers,Suzanne, "I've Discovered Sound," Brainworks, 2009, Leopard, page 9
  6. Camman, Donald M, "Historical Sketch: Stethoscopes," A Reference Handbook for Medical Sciences, edited by Albert Henry Buck, by various writers, volume VI, 1888, New York, William Wood and Company, 626-628
RT Cave on Twitter
Print Friendly and PDF

Wednesday, June 15, 2016

1808: Corvisart re-introduces chest percussion to medicine

Jean Nicolas Corvisart (1755-1821) was the
mentor and teacher of two men who would go
on to gain fame studying diseases of the chest:
 Matthew Baillie and Rene Laennec.
Another pupil of his was Marie-Francois-
Xavier Bichat, the founder of biology. 
Joseph Avenbrugger introduced the medical community to chest percussion in 1761, although his idea was flat out rejected by many and rarely used by those who learned of it.  It would be another 53 years before his idea would be accepted, and it would take the efforts of a famous physician by the name of Jean Nicolas Corvisart des Merets (1755-1821). 

J.F. Halls Dally, in a 1941 article, said Corvisart was born February 15, 1755, to Pierre Corvisart, an advocate and attorney to the Parliament of Paris. For part of his childhood he lived with an uncle who was a priest at Vimille.  He then started college at Sainte-Barbe at the age of 12, where he was a "mediocre pupil who favored of outdoor sports. (1, page 239)

Of Corvisart's childhood education, Dally said: 
He is said to have left the college almost as ignorant as when he went in, with no reputation but that of an incorrigible idler. Thus the childhood of Corvisart gave no promise of his brilliant future. (1, page 239)
Later on he started as a law student, but after spending time at medical clinics of Paris he became interested in medicine. He became particularly interested in the speeches of Dr. Anthony Petit, a professor of anatomy and medicine. It was this reason "the young Corvisart recognized the profession for which he was designed. He longed to study the animal economy, and for this purpose he determined to be a physician," said Baron Cuvier in his 1830 memoir of Corvisart. (2, page 81) (1, page 23)

Surreptitiously, as he didn't want his father to be disappointed, he attended the lectures of the most famous physicians of the day, including Petit and Pierre Joseph Desault, said Cuvier. His father ultimately found out and approved of his transfer to the medical profession. (2, page 81)

Dally said he paid his way through medical school by becoming a male nurse at at Hotel Dieu, the oldest hospital in Paris.  It was here he became greatly influenced by the surgeon Pierre Joseph Desault, chief surgeon of the Hotel Dieu. Corvisart observed diseases with him and and examined bodies.  He also delivered his own lectures on anatomy and physiology, and these were well received.  He soon became well liked by his fellow students and physicians. (1, page 239)(2, page 81)

He was offered a job as physician at Necker, although he declined this position because all who held it had to wear a particular wig that had been handed down for decades.  Other clinics had given up this tradition, but it was still alive at Necker.  When he was offered a choice of taking the job and wearing the wig, or keeping his hair, he said he'd prefer to keep his hair.  This was a minor set back, however, because other opportunities awaited him. (1, page 240)(2, page 81)

It's interesting to note that while medicine in other areas of Europe had moved forward by leaps and bounds, Cuvier said medicine in France remained much as it was in the middle ages when the Faculty of Paris was formed. He said:
Besides, there were no public lectures at the beds of the sick. In order to see a few patients, the students accompanied the elder physicians in their visits; afterwords, when these physicians were unwell, or too much busied with practice, they acted for them, and thus they continued, till at length they, too, slowly attained their professional rank. (2, page 81)
Desbois de Rochfort (1750-1786)
In 1788 he became elected as physician at Necker hospital. His predecessor was Desbois de Rochfort, (Rochfort had passed away) chief physician at Le Charite, who was the...
...real creator of clinical medicine in France.  The pupil thus succeeded the master, and the glory of the master gained added lustre. Corvisart took over the clinical teaching and from that moment his reputation, already established among his colleagues and students, began to spread outside the confines of the hospital." (1, page 240)(2, page 81)
However, unlike his predecessors, he believed it was best to diagnose diseases by their signs and symptoms and pathological anatomy, as opposed to guessing what might be found on autopsy.  (1, page 240)

Then things change for the worse in France. Although the end result would benefit the medical profession of France.  Dally said:
In 1793 the Reign of Terror began.  The medical schools were shut, anyone could call himself a doctor and treat the sick.  Medical education was three centuries behind the times. But out of the Revolution grew modern medical education.  In the new schools of Paris laboratories were instituted for scientific study; students were taught at the bedside in hospital after the manner of Sydenham.  And it was Corvisart -- formerly rejected because he wore no wig, who taught, who for he had now become the leading professor in France. He acquired the natural history of disease by collecting observations, and when possible, following the example of Morgagni, he noted from dissection and from autopsy the changes in the body that caused symptoms of disease.  His chief lectures were given at the Necker hospital, and subsequently over a term of fifteen years at Cochin Hospital." (1, page 240)
Corvisart, whose reputation increased daily, lived in close contact with the most illustrious men of the time.  In 1795, on the criterion of the first school of medicine in Paris, he was unanimously elected to fill the Chair of Clinical Medicine, for the first time included as part of public education in France. Two years later, in 1797, he was made Professor of Medicine at the College de France. (1, page 240-241) 
While Corvisart was professor of medicine at the Charite Hospital in Paris, he studied the works of Auenbrugger and found the technique of percussion useful in diagnosing his own patients.

He championed for percussion when he re-published Abenbrugger's booklet about percussion Inventum Novum in 1808.  While he didn't have to, he humbly gave credit for the discovery of percussion to Avenbrugger.

He wrote:
"I could have raised myself to the rank of an author by remodeling the work of Auenbrugger and publishing a work on percussion.  But by that I would sacrifice the name of Auenbrugger to my own vanity; that I do not wish to do: it belongs to him, it is his beautiful and rightful discovery which I wish to bring to life." (1, page 242-243)
While Corvisant supported Avenbrugger's general technique, he adjusted it slightly so that "he used the palmar surface of the extended and approximated fingers," said Alex Sakula. (6, page 576)

Corvisart used the technique to help diagnose patients with tuberculosis and other diseases of the chest.  Based on the sounds emitted he would be able to tell how large or small the tubercles inside a patient were, along with their locations. (3)

Corvisart and his students -- one of whom was Rene Laennec -- were believed to be the only physicians in the world who used percussion. Perhaps this was because Corvisart was among the few physicians who studied Auenbrugger's work.

The use of percussion was among the diagnostic techniques used by Corvisart.  He used percussion, took a pulse, listened to the patients lung sounds by placing his ear on his patient's chest, watched the patient's breathing, felt for a temperature, observed sputum and perspiration, color of the patient's skin, changes in the voice, etc.  (2, page 81)

This was the new medical diagnostic practice that had already engulfed the medical profession throughout much of Europe, all but for the exception of chest percussion and, maybe also, vocal fremitis (vibration felt by the hand on the chest when a person speaks.  Different diseases would produce different sounds, according to the Free Dictionary by Farlex).

The Catholic Encyclopedia notes that Corvisant may have been the first to describe the technique of vocal fremitis, which is where a hand is placed over the patient's chest, and the patient is asked to make a sound, such as "a" or "e."  The physician then notes the vibratjions (fremitis) felt as the person made these sounds. Corvisart found this to be another very useful procedure in diagnosing diseases of the chest.  (5)

So, in this way, Corvisart was able to add to the list of diagnostic tools used by European physicians of his era.  By using these tools, Corvisart, and based on his studies of bodies, was able to match changes on the outside of the body with changes that might be occurring inside the body.  He was, therefore, able to use observation and science to diagnose.

In this way, he was able to use observation and science to diagnose patient, as opposed to using theory and just guessing.  Perhaps it was this that most impressed the emperor of France.

Napoleon Bonaparte was a famous military leader and
emperor of France. In these days, the best,
and perhaps only, means of adapting new ideas
was to earn the respect of the ruling party.

The technique of chest percussion may not even have been adapted by the medical profession at all if not for Emperor Napolean Bonaparte (1769-1821) selecting Corvisart as his own personal physician.  (4)

Dally said Corvisart was recommended as physician to Bonaparte because he was impressed that Corvisart used a scientific technique instead of simply guessing what was wrong, as other physicians of his era did.

Some speculate it was Boneparte who convinced Corvisart to write his first book, a treaties on diseases of the heart. This work was significant to our history of asthma because it was among the essential steps needed for future physicians to pluck cardiac disorders that caused dyspnea out from under the umbrella term asthma. (1, page 243)

Of this, Dally said:
It is said that cardiology as such did not exist prior to Corvisart's work. He really created cardiac symptomatology, and established differential diagnosis between cardiac and pulmonary disease, as well as between functional and organic heart disease." (1, page 243)
Corvisart later wrote his commentaries on Auenbrugger, which was also well received by his peers. (1, page 241)(2, page 82)

Thanks to the writings of Corvisart, and later Rene Laennec, Auenbrugger's discovery would become readily accepted shortly after his death in 1807, and Auenbrugger would eventually go down as one of the great minds in medical history.

Auenbrugger did, however, live "just long enough to witness the beginning of a proper recognition of his discovery," said Dally. (1, page 243)

Of course Corvisart himself would also go down as one of the great minds in medical history, not just because he re-introduced chest percussion to medicine, but because was a great physician overall who left an indelible impression on the medical profession.

He developed apoplexy (stoke symptoms) that took away his ability to perform his job, but not his mind.  He then suffered a cardiac arrest on September 18, 1821. He left behind no family, although he left much to his family of physicians.  (2, page 82)

Further reading:
  1. Laennec, the inventor of the stethoscope
  2. Auenbrugger introduced chest percussion to medical profession
References:
  1. Dally, J.F. Halls, "Life and times of Jean Nicolas Corvisart (1755-1821)," Proc R Soc Med., March, 1941, 34 (5), pages 239-246
  2. Baron, Cuvier, "Biographical Memoir of M. Corvisart," Literary Port Folia, Thursday, March 18, 1830, No. 11, Philadelphia, pages 81-82
  3. "The Catholic Encyclopedia, "Leopold Auenbrugger," http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/02072a.htm
  4. Williams, Henry Smith, "The Century's Progress in Scientific Medicine," Harper's Magazine, 1899, page 3
  5. "The Catholic Encyclopedia, "Leopold Auenbrugger," http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/02072a.htm
  6. Sakula, Alex., "Pierre Adolphe Piorry (1794-1879): pioneer of percussion and pleximetry," October, 1979, Thorax ( 34(5): 575–581).  
RT Cave Facebook Page
RT Cave on Twitter
Print Friendly and PDF